
The Sandinista lesson on bureaucracy, power and the absence of popular control
In July 2026, forty-seven years after the victory of the Sandinista revolution and the fall of the Somoza dictatorship, Daniel Ortega announced that Nicaragua would hold no new elections. The man who entered history as one of the leaders of a popular revolution that overthrew a US-backed family dictatorship now heads a regime centred on a new family power, in which his wife Rosario Murillo holds the post of “co-president”, amid the steady shrinking of space for independent political activity.
This transformation may look like a cruel historical paradox: a revolution against the rule of the Somoza family ending in a regime whose name is tied to the Ortega–Murillo family.
But reducing the question to Ortega alone means missing the most important lesson. The problem is not only that a revolutionary leader turned into an authoritarian ruler, but the broader question raised by the Nicaraguan experience:
How do revolutions, when their institutions become detached from their social base, turn into state apparatuses whose main concern is preserving power rather than widening the participation of the masses who made them?
From revolution to state
The Sandinista revolution of 1979 was one of the outstanding moments of liberation struggle in the twentieth century. It overthrew the Somoza dictatorship that had ruled Nicaragua for decades – a dictatorship whose interests were bound up with the local economic elites and with US political and military support.
The Sandinista National Liberation Front came to power amid broad popular hopes. It promised to build a fairer society by fighting illiteracy, expanding health and education services, redistributing wealth and ending political and economic dependency on Washington.
But the Sandinista revolution was born into a hostile international environment.
The United States saw the Sandinista victory as a threat to its interests in Central America, so it backed the Contra war against the new government and imposed an economic blockade and political pressure that lasted for years.
This factor cannot be ignored. US imperialism played a fundamental role in weakening and besieging the Sandinista experience.
At the same time, however, foreign intervention cannot become the only explanation for all the crises of the revolution. Revolutionary experiences do not only face external enemies; they also face the danger of internal transformation when the institutions born of popular struggle begin to detach themselves from the society that produced them.
When the leadership replaces the masses
The Nicaraguan experience reveals a historical problem that has confronted many revolutionary movements: the problem of bureaucracy, and of the state apparatus becoming a force independent of society.
When a revolutionary movement triumphs and takes over the institutions of the state, a fundamental contradiction appears: does the state become a tool in the hands of the masses to organise social change, or does it gradually turn into a centre of power that takes the place of popular participation?
The danger begins when the masses shift from being the main actor in the revolutionary process to being a mere audience asked to endorse the decisions taken by the leadership.
At that point the party replaces the movement, the state replaces society, and the leadership replaces the masses. Here lies the heart of the deviation.
Socialism, from a revolutionary perspective, is not simply the state holding power or confronting imperialism. The essence of the socialist project is that the popular classes themselves become the decision-makers, through their independent organisation and their ability to monitor and hold to account those who represent them.
From resisting imperialism to justifying power
There is no doubt that the history of the United States in Latin America is full of interventions, coups and support for dictatorships that served its interests. Nicaragua itself was one of the most prominent examples.
But the revolutionary left cannot fall into the error of turning anti-imperialism into a justification for accepting any policy pursued by a government that raises anti-imperialist slogans.
National liberation is incomplete without social and political liberation.
Confronting Washington does not mean silencing workers, students or opponents.
And raising the slogans of the revolution does not put those in power above criticism and accountability.
A revolution that loses the masses’ ability to monitor and criticise their leadership begins to lose its essence, even if its symbols and slogans are still held high.
Nicaragua: a lesson that goes beyond Nicaragua
The Sandinista experience is not an isolated case in history.
Throughout the twentieth century, the world witnessed many experiences that began as genuine popular revolutions but ended as bureaucratic regimes that closed off mass participation, in which the institutions of the revolution became state institutions defending their own continuity.
The problem was not the dream of social justice, nor the struggle against foreign domination, but the building of apparatuses of power detached from society.
That is why the question Nicaragua poses is not only:
Why did Ortega become what he is today?
But a more important question:
How do we protect the revolution from becoming a power above the revolution?
From Latin America to Syria: a question for the revolutionary left
For the revolutionary left in our region, the Nicaraguan experience carries particular importance.
In our region too, national liberation movements faced similar contradictions: regimes stepped forward raising the slogans of resistance to colonialism and imperialism, while at the same time repressing their peoples and preventing any political or social independence of the masses.
The revolutionary equation cannot be: “We are resisting our external enemy, therefore we have the right to repress at home.”
Real liberation does not set national liberation against social liberation; it binds them together.
A revolution that defeats an external power but prevents its people from organising, criticising and holding to account has achieved only half its task – and has dug the grave of the revolutionary process with its own hands.
Defending the revolution means defending its spirit
Defending the legacy of the Sandinista revolution does not mean defending everything its later leadership did in its name.
Nor does criticising Ortega mean repeating the discourse of the imperialist powers, which have historically used issues of democracy and human rights as tools to serve their interests.
A genuinely revolutionary position rejects both. The revolution is not just a government, the party is not the state, and the leader is not the people.
The revolution remains alive only when the masses are able to organise, participate, criticise, hold to account and run the country, by building their own bodies of power and organisations from below.
The greatest danger to a revolution is not only its enemies who seek to defeat it, but also the moment when the revolutionary leadership begins to detach itself from – and to fear – the popular masses who made the revolution.
Prepared by the Editorial Board of Frontline (Al-Khatt Al-Amami)

