
Frontline – Editorial Board
After more than a decade without direct flights between Syria and a number of European countries, these flights are gradually returning. Last July, Germany and the HTS (Hay’at Tahrir al-Sham) authority signed an air transport agreement, followed by the resumption of direct flights between Germany and Damascus. At the same time, the return and deportation of Syrians from Europe is no longer a remote political debate: in 2025 EU countries issued more than 16,000 return decisions against Syrians, while the number of those actually returning rose compared with the previous year.
As for Europe’s ruling governments, they are now ready to draw closer to and strike deals with an authority whose past and present leave no room to describe it as anything less than a terrorist force – so long as this cooperation serves the interests of their states, their ruling classes and their domestic political needs. The Thermidorian authority, which since arriving in Damascus has sought to consolidate its rule through external recognition, finds in these agreements another opportunity to present itself as a partner that regional and imperialist states can deal with.
But behind the mutual interests of both sides, the most important question for millions of Syrians goes unasked: to which Syria will these people return?
Deportation deals on the ruins of an exhausted society
The problem is not Syrians returning to their country as such. It is natural that millions of refugees want to return to the cities, villages and homes they were forced to leave. The problem begins when return is turned from a right – one that should be backed by the conditions for a safe and dignified life – into a deportation process decided from above by governments, in cooperation with an authority that cannot secure the conditions of life even for those already living in the country.
To which Syria will refugees and those forcibly deported return?
The government formed by HTS did not treat the period after the fall of the Assad clan’s junta regime as an opportunity to rebuild society on the basis of the interests of the workers, the toiling and the impoverished who paid the price of war and tyranny. Since arriving in Damascus as the victorious party among the forces of counter-revolution, it chose to follow a savage neoliberal economic path, accompanied by the arbitrary dismissal of state employees – in many cases linked to exclusion on religious, ethnic or political grounds. It also worked to shrink the role of the public sector and threw the doors wide open to capital and private investment, without any serious project to restart the productive economy or provide work and social protection for the masses.
If the Syrian economy is unable to provide jobs for those living inside it, and if the authority itself is increasing the number of unemployed through dismissals, lay-offs and its economic policies – alongside the rising cost of living, collapsing infrastructure and poor services – then on what basis is it taking in additional numbers of deportees?
When carrying a weapon becomes a job opportunity
Unemployment in Syria today has a political consequence far more dangerous than a mere fall in living standards. A young man who cannot find work – or whose wage, if he does, cannot secure him the bare minimum of life – does not have unlimited choices. The more civilian and productive jobs decline, the more important the institutions able to offer a regular salary and a livelihood become. This is where the security and military apparatus comes in. The destruction of civilian economic alternatives expands the authority’s capacity to recruit sections of the youth into its armed institutions. When the factory, the school, the hospital or the public institution cannot offer a job, while the security apparatus can offer a salary, a weapon and influence, material need itself becomes one of the tools for building the apparatus of power. A sectarian security apparatus is not built through ideological incitement alone; it also needs a material base, and individuals who find in joining it a way to get work, income and privilege.
Thus neoliberalism merges with reaction and repression in the complete form of the Syrian Thermidor: an authority that applies economic policies which deepen marginalisation and unemployment, works to reproduce sectarian and ethnic divisions in society, and seeks to expand its security and military apparatus in order to crush any voice of opposition.
A sectarian security apparatus is not built through ideological incitement alone; it also needs a material base
If this is the situation of the young people in Syria today, what will happen when they are joined by new numbers of deportees, many of whom will return with no work, no property and no social networks able to support them?
What rehabilitation under an authority of massacres?
The question becomes even more serious when it comes to deporting perpetrators of crimes and those proven to be involved in terrorist organisations. There is no need to deny or downplay this problem. But a crime does not disappear when its perpetrator is put on a plane to Damascus. If someone commits a crime, the responsibility of the state and the judicial institutions is not limited to punishment; it also includes trial, rehabilitation and social reintegration. Deportation does not solve the problem; it merely moves it geographically, from a society with greater capacity for accountability and rehabilitation to one whose economic and social institutions are collapsing.
The question here is not only whether the Syrian authority is capable of rehabilitating these people, but whether it is interested in doing so at all.
The bloody authority that has ruled Syria over the past year and a half has given a practical answer about its relationship with violence and its perpetrators. From the coast to Suwayda and on to Sheikh Maqsoud, crime, humiliation and the violation of human dignity have been sufficient proof that violence is a cornerstone of the structure of the Thermidorian authority. The farcical show trials accompanying the investigations into, and the supposed accountability for, those involved in abducting Syrian girls – Alawite girls in particular – are further evidence of the close structural relationship between terror and the ruling authority in Damascus.
Here the question becomes legitimate: if the authority does not hold to account those who commit crimes and carry weapons within the areas under its control and influence, why should we assume that it will suddenly become an institution capable of rehabilitating those among the forcibly returned who need rehabilitation?
Impunity and the recycling of violence
Under an authority seeking to expand its security apparatus, and in an economy that pushes growing numbers of young people to the margins, some individuals with a history of violence can become material to be absorbed into these very apparatuses. The authority has not only failed to make violence against civilians a bar to remaining in its apparatus; it has also created the conditions that allow violence to be recycled, and even rewarded, when it serves its interests.
From the coast to Suwayda and on to Sheikh Maqsoud, crime, humiliation and the violation of human dignity have been sufficient proof that violence is a cornerstone of the structure of the Thermidorian authority
Receiving growing numbers of deportees without jobs or reintegration programmes – among them people who need serious rehabilitation programmes – will not rebuild Syria. It means adding more unemployment, poverty and marginalisation to a society already suffering from them, and supplying more people whom the sectarian apparatus of power, gangs and various obscurantist groups can compete to recruit.
Here lies the danger of agreements presented as diplomatic victories: a shattered Syrian society caught between bourgeois governments that want to offload the burden of their internal crises onto it, and a Thermidorian authority seeking recognition, legitimacy and the resources needed to consolidate its rule, while it continues to deepen the devastation at home.
For an independent revolutionary social force
But confronting this reality does not mean demanding that Syria be closed to Syrians, nor treating deportees and the unemployed as a danger to be feared. The problem is not their return, but the imposition of return to a country where the conditions for a dignified return have not been built. The problem is not the unemployed, but the system that produces unemployment. It is not the young people looking for a livelihood, but the authority that makes carrying a weapon one of the few ways to get one. That is why a solution cannot be expected from the regional and international powers that deal with Syrians according to their own interests, nor from the Thermidorian authority and its security institutions, which are a central part of the very problem they are supposed to solve.
The alternative begins with the independent organisation of workers, young people, the toiling and the oppressed, and with the struggle for the right to work, wages, housing, services, freedoms and equality – that is, for the masses’ right to a dignified life and a better future, whether they stay in Syria or return to it. But these battles cannot remain scattered and isolated. A strike here, a sit-in there, resistance to arbitrary dismissal in one place, a protest against a sectarian crime in another – all of them need to connect with each other and become an independent social and political force, capable of breaking the sectarian and ethnic boundaries within which the authority and the reactionary forces try to imprison the masses.
What is needed is to build an independent revolutionary social force: the force of workers, young people, the toiling and all the oppressed
Faced with an authority of massacres, it is not enough to look for a less brutal executioner. Faced with unemployment and poverty, the choice cannot be to join the apparatus of those who create and guard this poverty. Faced with dependence on the outside, we cannot wait for a regional or international imperialist power to decide what future Syrian society deserves.
What is needed is to build an independent revolutionary social force – the force of workers, young people, the toiling and all the oppressed – capable of confronting the Thermidorian authority and of standing up to the obscurantism, sectarianism, racism and fascism that are rearing their heads and threatening everyone.
This force alone can wrest the future of young people from the machinery of repression, free society from the rule of fear and sectarianism, and open the way to a country where young people are not forced to choose between unemployment and the rifle, and where human beings are not bargaining chips traded by governments according to their interests – a country where the liberation of human beings, their lives and their dignity is the starting point of any future worth fighting for.






